For Over 30 Years

Aggressive Personal Injury
Legal Representation

blog home Medical Malpractice Medical Malpractice Suits and the Ineffectiveness of Tort Reforms

Medical Malpractice Suits and the Ineffectiveness of Tort Reforms

By Grant Law Office on September 9, 2013

The second-highest New York medical malpractice suit payout was recently awarded by a jury to a Long Island family, a staggering $130 million. An $8 million settlement was offered and rejected before the trial was initiated.

The trial, Reilly v. St. Charles Hospital, revolved around a birth gone wrong, where a child was born in 2002 with severe brain injury and cerebral palsy. The jury determined the cause of the injury to be malpractice on the part of the Long Island hospital. The obstetric nurse assigned to the birth missed signs of distress by the baby, an oversight that led to devastating consequences. The plantiff’s attorney argued that the medical errors were preventable, and the jury agreed.

The lawyers who represented St. Charles Hospital expressed discontentment with the trial’s outcome and pushed for more tort reform. Unlike 29 other states, New York does not limit the amount a claimant can be awarded for pain-and-suffering. The state also has a less restrictive statute of limitations for medical malpractice suits.

Tort Reforms are Not the Answer

According to advocates of tort reform, doctors are forced to prescribe unwarranted and expensive tests to patients due to anxiety over medical malpractice suits. They believe that lower medical malpractice awards and a shorter statute of limitations leads to reduced medical malpractice insurance premiums and, consequently, decreased health-care costs. However, research conducted by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and other credible groups has shown otherwise.

Researchers found no significant correlation between medical malpractice lawsuits and malpractice insurance rates. States with extensive tort reform measures still experienced increases in insurance premiums. Although the rate increases in those states were less than that of states with no tort reform, the difference was so slight as to be negligible. Rather, the solution to rising costs is improved procedures that ensure that medical professionals adhere to the standard of care so patients are not injured by malpractice.

Contact an Experienced Attorney for your Medical Malpractice Case

If you believe you have suffered an illness or injury due to medical malpractice, get in touch with the Atlanta medical negligence attorneys at The Law Offices of Wayne Grant, P.C. We have the experience and the knowledge to thoroughly investigate all aspects of your case and locate strong evidence that can support your claim. Call us now at (404) 995-3955 for a free and confidential case review.

Related Articles:

Posted in: Medical Malpractice

Contact us today for a free and comprehensive case evaluation.

We require no legal retainer or upfront fees,
and you pay nothing unless we prevail.

Phone: (404) 995-3955

Our Results

Wrongful Death Day Care Case

View More

Firm News

Susan G. Komen 3-Day for the Cure

Kim Grant participated in the Susan G. Komen 3-Day for the Cure, walking over 60 miles over three days and raising ...

Habitat for Humanity

Kim and Wayne Grant have worked on two Habitat for Humanity Houses and look forward to working on more ...

Grady Hospital Volunteer Work

Kim Grant has donated volunteer hours in Atlanta, including rocking babies in the neonatal intensive care unit at Grady ...

Read more news

Our Blog


Treadmill Entrapments and How to Prevent Them

The recent recall of Peloton+ treadmills has put a lot of workout enthusiasts on edge about the safety…


Announcing the 2021 Winner of the Best Foot Forward Scholarship

Since announcing the finalists for the Best Foot Forward Scholarship on May 4th, Grant Law Office has been…


Spotting Infections Caused by Road Rash

Road rash is a painful but common injury in motorcycle and bicycle accidents, occurring when a rider falls…

Read more news

Grant Law Office Disclaimer: The legal information offered herein by Grant Law Office, is not formal legal advice, nor is it the formation of an attorney client relationship. In order for our firm to be considered your attorney there must be a signed agreement between the client and the firm. Any results set forth herein are based solely upon the circumstances of that particular case and offer no promise or guarantee on the outcome of any other case. Please contact a lawyer for a consultation.

© 2021 Grant Law Office - All rights reserved.

Photos by Carroll Morgan - Buckhead On-Site Photography | Website Design and Legal Internet Marketing by: SLS Consulting Scholarship
*Wayne Grant has been practicing law since 1979. Grant Law Office was founded in 2000.


What you need to know about the 2-year statute of limitation law

Worried that the 2-year statute of limitations is rapidly approaching on your serious injury or medical malpractice case? Contact us and we can talk to you about the Judicial Emergency declared by the Supreme Court of Georgia and how it affects the statute of limitations for your case (in a good way.) Please call or email us through our web contact form and we would be happy to discuss your case.

Schedule a free consultation